The Real McCoy Distiller’s Proof Rum 5 Years Old, which is the same product as The Real McCoy Aged Rum Single Blended 5 Yr 92 but with a different name. It gave the rum a rating of B+, which means it is very good but not exceptional. It says the rum has a classic rum structure with notes of chewy caramel and flambéed banana on the palate, but also a spicy cinnamon punch and a bit of astringency on the finish.